• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Rafael’s Italian Restaurant - Shelbyville: Authentic Italian Dining Experience

Rafael’s Italian Restaurant in Shelbyville is a culinary gem, offering a diverse menu that delights both residents and visitors. Located at 1200 Madison St, this lively eatery is known for its generous toppings on pizzas, making them a standout choice for takeout enthusiasts like Audrey Garris. With dishes ranging from succulent steak quesadillas to enticing pizzas, the restaurant excels in delivering consistent quality and attentive service, as noted by satisfied customers like Cisco Mantanona. While some dishes may vary in experience, the warm atmosphere and commitment to flavor invite patrons to explore their enticing culinary offerings time and again.

Rafael’s Italian Restaurant - Shelbyville at a glance

  • Address 1200 Madison St, Shelbyville, TN 37160, United States
  • Phone +1 931-684-9170
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant , Fast food restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Rafael’s Italian Restaurant - Shelbyville: Reviews & Ratings

Audrey Garris (13audrey)
5

One of the best take out pizzas I’ve ever had! Very generous on their toppings. I will for sure be a repeat customer anytime I’m in Shelbyville!

Cisco Mantanona
5

This has been our go to since relocating back to Shelbyville. The wide variety of dishes and cuisines isn't easy to do, but they handle it flawlessly!! Go here, peruse the menu, I guarantee that something will grab your attention!! Consistent quality, and the staff is always nice.

William Johnson
5

Steak quesadillas are the best I have ever had anywhere and the rice for side is perfect option.i have been to several locations and they were all ok but this location is always the best. Tullahoma not so much.

Mark Klopf
3

Was in town for the weekend. First night we ordered meals. All were underwhelming. Okay, but nothing to write home about. The lasagna I ordered was about equivalent to what I'd expect from a frozen one with a better sauce. The garlic bread was a sub roll with some garlic butter and the bread sticks were honestly the best part with the sauce. Second night, we noticed the first night they had but 1 get one free pizza. These things look great! I haven't tasted them yet because I'm not hungry yet, but they have that perfectly browned spots on the cheese where they're cooked just long enough and given the bread sticks the dough and the sauce from last night I'm expecting good things. The chicken wings last night left some to be desired. The skin wasn't browned, but they were properly cooked. A lack of options for sauces was disappointing. The meatball sub was disappointing in every way. Size and flavor were underwhelming.

Laura Sefton
5

Great food, and service. Only thing is I wish their booths were a little bigger. We had to use a chair to put one of the pizzas on.

Olivya Perry
4

Good food at great prices. Very casual atmosphere. Order at the counter, sit and they bring it to you.

Location

  • Rafael’s Italian Restaurant - Shelbyville
    Rafael’s Italian Restaurant - Shelbyville
    1200 Madison St, Shelbyville, TN 37160, United States Hotline: +1 931-684-9170

Welcome to Rafael’s Italian Restaurant, nestled in the heart of Shelbyville, Tennessee. This culinary gem at 1200 Madison St serves as a magnet for locals and visitors alike, thanks to its delightful blend of authentic Italian cuisine and comforting crowd-pleasers.

The inviting atmosphere is matched by a menu that boasts a wide array of dishes, perfectly suited to satisfy any craving. From hearty pizzas, praised by customers such as Audrey Garris, who raves about their generous toppings, to flavorful steak quesadillas that have captivated patrons like William Johnson, there’s something for everyone. It's clear why many consider Rafael’s their go-to spot after moving back to the area, as noted by Cisco Mantanona, who appreciates the restaurant’s consistent quality and diverse offerings.

One of the highlights of Rafael’s is undoubtedly their pizzas, available for takeout or dining in. The promise of perfectly browned, flavorful crust paired with fresh ingredients is enough to tempt even the most discerning of diners. On my visit, I could taste the rich flavor combinations that come from careful preparation and a love for the craft. However, not every experience has been flawless, as noted by Mark Klopf, who shared mixed feelings about certain dishes. This only underscores the restaurant's commitment to improvement and consistency.

Moreover, the attentive staff ensure that your dining experience is as enjoyable as the food itself. Despite a few critiques regarding the want for larger booth spaces or a wider variety of options for sides, many guests, like Laura Sefton, still find the overall service and food quality to be commendable.

Whether you're a returning local or just passing through, Rafael’s Italian Restaurant in Shelbyville is a delightful spot to indulge in Italian classics and creative dishes. From tempting appetizers to delectable main courses, you’re bound to find a dish that will leave you longing for more. Don’t miss out on this charming eatery the next time you’re in town!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards